“Heat not burn is getting a lot more attention, [and] partly that may be because some states have increased excise taxes on combustible tobacco, and consumers tend to look at alternatives when that happens,” says MSA’s Don Burke, who notes that smoking bans are also fueling the trend. “When smoking is prohibited, people move toward a smoke-free type of tobacco, such as snus or heat not burn.”
However, just as key may be the fact that innovation, which has always driven the heat not burn category, has continued unabated in the deeming regulations’ wake. Under the regulation, new heat not burn products introduced after Feb. 15, 2007, would have to show that they meet the applicable public health standard set by the law and receive marketing authorization from the FDA.
Given the cost and complexity of navigating the FDA’s labyrinthine new tobacco product application process, many anticipated a dearth of R&D in its wake.
Yet that hasn’t been the case, possibly due to the FDA’s announcement of an extension for the new product application deadline. “Five years is enough time for manufacturers to pay off any new product development costs and also opens up the possibility for more change,” says Burke. “It’s a broad enough window for people to think, ‘Who knows what will happen by then?’”
Whatever the cause, 2017’s flurry of innovation is driving interest in the category. “Both new technology and new products have been introduced, including improvements on Vuse and MarkTen and a hybrid Vapeleaf product from Logic, as well as Juul’s new product, which really hit big,” says Burke.
Surprisingly, despite healthy sales overall, e-liquid sales have been declining—an indication that the open systems once viewed as promising are losing steam with vapers. E-liquid volume sales are down by 33 percent in tobacco outlets and by 59 percent in c-stores, according to MSA’s research. By contrast, cartridge volume is up by 15 percent in outlets and by 20 percent in c-stores.
“What is coming on are heat not burnizers, devices where you just put in a cartridge,” says Burke.
“Those are really starting to drive this category.” Offering both convenience and greater safety, closed-system vaping devices appeal to a wider array of customers, especially now that the latest product introductions offer a better experience than their less sophisticated predecessors.